We now live in a post-literate society where the majority of people no longer use reading and writing as a way to gain information or to entertain themselves.
Of course, there are still some bookworms out there, but they only read books out of their own individual interest. This started with the arrival of television, and now we have hit an all-time low.
According to the Washington Post, as of 2023, only 16% of all Americans read for pleasure. The study by researchers at the University of Florida and University College London showed that leisure reading has fallen by 40 percent in the past 20 years.
As if social media and unlimited screen time weren’t bad enough for books, the arrival of generative AI gave rise to automated video summaries and AI overviews that can give anyone interested in a book the synopsis, leading to even fewer people reading.
However, what people today often don’t realize is that summaries fail to capture the true essence of a book. Let’s explore why book summaries can’t replace reading the full story.
Most Book Summaries are Now AI-Generated
In the past, people who actually read the books took the time to summarize them. And, while the summary was still lacking and may even have reflected their preferential bias, they were still closer to the book.
These days, most book summaries are AI-generated. Even Google’s AI overview summary is, at the end of the day, still AI. This is why the summaries you find now tend to be quite generic. The words only capture the story on a surface level.
Remember that the plot of many books sounds cliché until you see the quality of the writer’s writing or get immersed in the narrative.
Moreover, AI summaries can also be filled with mistakes and even hallucinations. So, even if you opt to read summaries, run them through an AI checker to make sure they are not automated. Even if you want to read a summary, choose the one that was summarized by an actual reader.
Summary Misses the Nuances
You may have heard the phrase “the beauty is in the details.” The concept behind the phrase could not be more accurate for books.
One of the crucial aspects that makes any book good is the intricate details laced into the plot. But when you read the summary, all you get is the plot and nothing else.
Any good writer plays with words, adds sensory descriptions, builds character quirks, reveals foreshadowing subtly, and so much more when crafting a book. And you miss all that when you read a summary.
This is often why summaries feel so underwhelming. Most books will not seem interesting in a summary because it leaves out all the nuances, and you just get to know what happens, without learning the details of how, when, and why.
Let’s say you read in a summary that something happens to the main character that leads them on a journey, but it may leave out what that actually was. This lack of context can pretty much ruin the tale for you.
You Don’t Just Read a Book, You Experience It
Unless you are reading a generic textbook, almost every other book tends to give you an experience. You are not just reading to know what happens; you are reading to experience the story.
For example, a good autobiographer would be able to make you go through their character development as you read their story; you will get surprised, depressed, amazed, overwhelmed, etc., alongside them.
So much work goes into a book to make sure you get completely immersed in the storyline. If you think about the Harry Potter series, what made it so unforgettable is that every child or adult who read it got sucked into the story, feeling every step of Harry’s journey.
Authors do this by adding intricate details and evocative imagery. The words ignite our senses, and we are teleported right into their tales. You won’t have that experiences with the summaries, it will just tell you the gist of it.
Missing Out on Writer’s Perspective, Tone, and Rhythm
What makes a book a good read is not just the story; it’s the way the writer presents the story. We have already talked about the added details and the sensory appeal, but more than that, whether one would read a book or leave it untouched depends heavily on the narration.
Many readers end up reading the same tropes and books on similar themes, but they do so because they know that different writers bring out their own perspective about the topic.
For example, if you consider Sarah J. Maas’s popular ACOTAR series, the first book, A Court of Thorns and Roses, is a retelling of Beauty and the Beast. Most people would come in and think it’s a more detailed and spicy version set in the land of Faerie.
Yet, when you go beyond the first book, you realize that the author completely dismantles it in the second book, and even the male lead changes. Anyone reading the summary of the first book will think, “Oh, it’s Beauty and the Beast,” but that couldn’t be further from the truth.
Final Thoughts
If you want to read summaries, do it to explore a new topic or to filter through many books to find a new read. But do not consider yourself a reader if you are just going to read the summary.
Even if a good, human-written summary will just tell you what happened and why it’s important, you will still be missing out on every element of the book that actually makes it good.
People don’t read a book to know the story; they read it for the beauty of the words and the dynamic narration, each varying according to an author’s skill. The plot is just the tip of the iceberg, and under it lies a whole new world you will never know unless you pick up a book and go through it.